Just east of the Moreno Valley, in the Cimarron country that shared the same Maxwell Land Grant world, one ranch tells the whole story of how this region was settled. The Chase Ranch, founded in 1867 by Manly and Theresa Chase, began as a small grant purchase and grew into an 11,000-acre working cattle ranch that stayed in the same family for four generations. For visitors driving the Enchanted Circle today, it is one of the clearest windows left into the ranching life that first put permanent homes, herds, and orchards across this high country.
Manly and Theresa Chase came from Wisconsin by way of Colorado and crossed Raton Pass in a covered wagon just after the Civil War. Manly purchased 1,000 acres from Lucien B. Maxwell, land that was part of the Maxwell Land Grant, along Ponil Creek about a mile north of the Cimarron River and not far from the Santa Fe Trail. The ranch ground included the old Kit Carson homestead, and the Chases built their home on land where Apache and Ute people had lived before them. Manly provided beef to local Native Americans, a practice remembered for helping the new ranch coexist peacefully with its neighbors.
The Chases started with sheep, and by 1875 Manly was raising cattle with Texas Longhorns and Corriente cattle. Hereford cattle, the breed the ranch would become known for, were introduced in 1883. Manly also planted an apple orchard that continues today, and he and Theresa raised six children in their 14-room ranch house. The ranch became famous for its heart-shaped brand, and much of its early history is unusually well documented because Manly kept more than 70 books of records, including daily diaries that are now held by the New Mexico State University Library.
The last family owner carried that record forward in remarkable fashion. Gretchen Sammis, Manly and Theresa's great-granddaughter, took over management of the ranch in 1954 after her grandfather died and ran it for 58 years, while also teaching in the Cimarron public schools for 26 years. She was a member of the National Cowgirl Hall of Fame and was named the 2007 New Mexico Cattleman of the Year, and the Cowgirl Museum's biography of her notes that she was the first woman to serve as president of the Northern New Mexico Livestock Association, the first woman on the Cimarron School Board, and the first woman to chair the Colfax County Soil and Water Conservation District.
Gretchen Sammis died in August 2012, and ownership passed to the Chase Ranch Foundation, which she had created to preserve the ranch and teach young people about ranching. On October 21, 2013, the foundation signed an agreement with the Boy Scouts of America for the neighboring Philmont Scout Ranch to keep the Chase Ranch running as a working cattle ranch with Herefords, preserve its historic structures, and operate a museum and living-history programs. In summer, tours visit the main house, the grounds, the orchards, and the tack room, so the heart-shaped brand is not just a story in a book. It is still a working ranch, and it still teaches the next generation how cattle country in northern New Mexico began.